Samuel's CFO Website

  • Home
  • CFO Blog
    • Samuel’s Other Blogs
      • CFO Moves
        • USA
        • Canada
        • UK
      • CHRO Moves
  • CFO Book
    • Buy your copy
    • What others have to say about Guide to CFO Success
  • How Samuel Helps
    • Hire your next CFO
    • Build your Finance Team
    • Financial Executive Coaching
    • CFO Peer Groups
    • Speaking & Training
  • About Samuel
    • Media on Samuel Dergel
  • Contact Samuel
  • English
  • Français
You are here: Home / Marketing Reporting to Finance? Surely the Sky Must be Falling.

May 12, 2015 By Samuel Dergel 4 Comments

Marketing Reporting to Finance? Surely the Sky Must be Falling.

The marketing world was all a twitter last week when it was announced that Twitter’s marketing group would now be reporting to the CFO.CFO on Twitter

I found the opinions and reporting from marketing folks to be very Chicken Little. Here are some reports.

Twitter gives control of its hapless marketing department to its chief financial officer – The Verge, May 5, 2015

Marketing Twitter – Six Pixels of Separation Blog by Mitch Joel from Mirum

CFO as Marketing Chief? Maybe Not as Unusual as You Think (or Maybe So) – Advertising Age, May 11, 2015

Most of my CFOs would shy away from taking responsibility for marketing, yet a good number of them have overall responsibility for important areas outside of Finance. Now, really, what does a Finance trained CFO understand about areas like Human resources and Information technology ?

The only important difference between HR and IT‎ and Marketing is that Marketing is seen as a lever to drive revenue, and that areas like IT and HR are good old support functions.

Yet, wait a minute.

  • Which C-Suite executive is looked at as a potential successor to the CEO?
  • Which ‎C-Suite leader is most often called upon to become Chief Operating Officer, either in conjunction with continuing as CFO or as a stand alone role?
  • Who at the executive table is volunteered for dealing with the most challenging and difficult parts of a business?

That’s right. The CFO.

Now what led Twitter decide to give overall responsibility of Marketing to its CFO in a company ‎who’s entire business is about marketing? We’ll never know for sure.

If there is one thing I’ve learned in my years in executive search and my weekly reporting on CFO Moves is that the official story and what is really happening behind the scenes can some times sound like they are fiction written in different genres.

But that won’t stop me (or others) from speculating.

In the Twitter situation, it seems that Marketing is falling under the purview of the CFO while the company is looking to hire their best next marketing leader.

The positives for Twitter of this temporary move could include:

  • Someone needs to take responsibility for this very important function. Why not Finance?
  • There could be no better way for the CFO to learn the marketing function than by taking responsibility. Most CFOs learn well under pressure.
  •  CFOs love to challenge the status quo. This is an opportunity to shake things up‎.

Most importantly, in a comp‎any where marketing is key to the product and the mission, the CFO needs to truly understand the value of marketing so they can say yes to the big dollars needed to fund the Twitter marketing machine.

So, is the sky falling?

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Comments

  1. Gary Cokins says

    May 18, 2015 at 7:54 AM

    Samuel … Although your suggestion will be viewed as radical it is points to an issue. There is a wide gap between the CFO and marketing and sales. It needs to be closed.

    Customers are the source of shareholder wealth creation. Marketing and sales’ goals have been to grow market share and increase sales. It should be to increase PROFITABLE sales. Accounting information helps answer which types of customers are attractive to retain, grow, win-back and acquire as well as how much to OPTIMALLY spend doing these with offers, deals, price discounts, and marketing campaigns. I explain why in this article I authored in this link:

    http://www.imanet.org/docs/default-source/sf/2015_02/02_2015_cokins.pdf?sfvrsn=2

    You have raised a relevant topic. Thanks.

    Gary … Gary Cokins

    Reply
    • Samuel Dergel says

      May 18, 2015 at 9:02 AM

      Thank you Gary.

      I fully agree that Finance has lots of room for improvement to assist Sales and Marketing functions, both at the C-suite level, as well as in the day-to-day interactions between the groups.

      I had one example just last week of a CFO coaching client of mine who went the extra mile on this exact topic, making a continuous significant impact on the bottom line with just one suggestion.

      The key part for the CFO is to be part of the conversation, and this takes planning and effort. Understanding the CFO Relationship Map is a good place to start. http://dergelcfo.com/2014/11/05/the-c-suite-relationship-map/

      Thanks for sharing Gary!

      Samuel

      Reply
  2. Peter Brandt says

    May 18, 2015 at 1:27 PM

    Hmm…I’m a finance under-grad major, who now does marketing. It’s been many years since that finance degree, and my learnings since then, have made me question what the fundementals of what business are, especially being in marketing roles.

    The first premise – the purpose of a business is to make and increase profit – my finance background.

    My marketing/sales insight since then – the purpose of a business is to satisfy customers.

    I know, many of you will say, just combine the two, then we’re on the right track.

    But, can you? When Amazon was going public and Jeff Bezos, a former investment banker by the way, was writing the first open shareholder letter, he emphasized customer satisfaction as the overarching goal of the company. And, purposely eschewed short-term profitability as playing a part in decision making. Mind you, at the time Amazon was selling books online, thinking about selling music, too. History now records Amazon as the model of how to create and run a successful internet company, and many, would argue, any company. The competitors at the time, Yahoo, AOL, eBay, etc., are now shadows of Amazon, having focused on short-term profits.

    Who is winning, and why?

    So, having marketing report to the CFO, what is the driving decision criteria?

    For marketeers, we strive to do many things. We do extensively use analytics now, true. But, the heart of marketing is about creating satisfied customers, especially long-term, loyal customers.

    For research, as most marketers still try to predict future markets, those analytics use financial data, true. But, that financial data is primarily aimed at predicting who are potential customers, how much could/would they pay for a product or service, and the predicted revenue. Costs? Let the design and operations people figure that out. Hence, profitability in the research scenario is secondary. The big question is, is there a market?

    For, creating a brand, positioning, creating awareness, again analytics are used, but moreso to determine impact of what’s happening. Are those customers, who supposedly ought to be buying that product/service, aware and engaging? This is mostly about customer counts, who’s looking/engaging where, how they are responding, etc. It’s all about the customer.

    Finally, actually moving customers to purchase – generating leads. Again, it’s about helping potential customers make good decisions in their buying process. It’s not about fooling them just enough to either buy on impulse, or getting them into a sales cycle either they or the company will live to regret. Can analytics be used to measure effectiveness, and ROI, yes, but to hone the marketing engagement process, content to improve? The objective is not to start with the premise of profitability, rather, what will work for customers.

    So, for me, the purpose for marketing, and the purpose for finance are not opposite, they should support each other. But, the question driving marketing should be what’s best for our customer? And, that should drive what gets done. Profitability can help measure the decisions, but as Amazon has illustrated, what’s most profitable at the moment, and what is best for the customer can be very different. As a marketer, I would go with the later, over the former, because that will sustain the company long term. Without customers, there is no profit.

    Will a CFO have this same outlook? Can they really just take profit into consideration, but really focus on customer needs? History says no.

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. EPM Channel | Marketing Reporting to Finance? Surely the Sky Must be Falling. says:
    June 15, 2015 at 5:47 AM

    […] By Samuel Dergel, from: http://dergelcfo.com/2015/05/12/marketing-reporting-to-finance-surely-the-sky-must-be-falling/ […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search in Samuel’s CFO Blog

Related Blogs

  • Your Next CFO
  • Why work with Stanton Chase to hire your next CFO?
  • Why do CFOs Leave?
  • When hiring a CFO, is LinkedIn the place to look?
  • What I learned at the Bank of America Merrll Lynch Conference – Treasury in a Connected World

Related Blogs

  • When should a CFO hire?
  • What I learned at the Bank of America Merrll Lynch Conference – Treasury in a Connected World
  • VIDEO: Webinar Presentation – CFO Succession: The Right Way to Grow your Company’s next CFO
  • Together, CFOs and CEOs Create A “Can Do” Culture
  • Thoughts About Successful CFO Hiring

Related Blogs

  • You’ve been promoted to CFO. Now what?
  • Why should a CFO tweet? 
  • What I learned at the Bank of America Merrll Lynch Conference – Treasury in a Connected World
  • What a CFO should read every day
  • Together, CFOs and CEOs Create A “Can Do” Culture

Related Blogs

  • Why should a CFO tweet? 
  • What I learned at the Bank of America Merrll Lynch Conference – Treasury in a Connected World
  • VIDEO: Webinar Presentation – CFO Succession: The Right Way to Grow your Company’s next CFO
  • Together, CFOs and CEOs Create A “Can Do” Culture
  • Thoughts About Successful CFO Hiring

Related Blogs

  • Your Next CFO
  • You’ve been promoted to CFO. Now what?
  • Why work with Stanton Chase to hire your next CFO?
  • Why should a CFO tweet? 
  • Why do CFOs Leave?

Recent Blogs

  • PODCAST: The Hiring Triangle – CEO, CFO and the Board
  • Is your CFO your best salesperson?
  • A CFO Success Story: Sajid Malhotra, CFO of Limelight Networks
  • What Makes a Great Modern CFO?
  • Things CFOs Say

Like what Samuel has to say?

Great! The goal of Samuel's CFO Blog is to engage with CFOs and those who work with CFOs.

Please feel free to comment on any of the issues raised in Samuel’s CFO Blog. Your input, positive or not so positive, encouraging or critical, will add value to all readers of the blog.

You can reach Samuel...
Telephone
San Francisco: +1 (415) 738-2070
Montreal: +1 (514) 907-0925
Email: [email protected]

View Samuel Dergel - The CFO Expert's profile on LinkedIn

Contact Samuel

So you like what Samuel has to say, and you would like to reach out and contact him.

Excellent.

There are a number of ways to reach him. You can complete this convenient form on the right, or you can reach Samuel by...

Telephone
San Francisco: +1 (415) 738-2070
Montreal: +1 (514) 907-0925

Or by clicking on the social media icons below.

Thanks for your interest!

Contactez Samuel

Vous vous intéressez à l’opinion de Samuel et souhaitez le consulter?

Excellent.

Vous pouvez le rejoindre de plusieurs façons, soit en complétant le formulaire ci-joint ou en le rejoignant :

Par téléphone : +1 (514) 907-0925

Ou en sélectionnant l’icône d’un réseau social ci-dessous:

Nous vous remercions de votre intérêt.

  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Archives – Samuel’s CFO Blog

Categories – Samuel’s CFO Blog

All of Samuel's Blogs Assessment Blog Board Board Books books for CFOs Build your Finance Team Career Management CEO CEO CFO CFO Buzz CFO Coach CFO Coaching CFO Consulting CFO Moves CFO Peer Groups CFO Relationships CFO Research CFO Search Chief Financial Officer Executive Coaching Executive Search Finance Team Financial Executive Coaching Great CFO Guide to CFO Success Hire your Next CFO How Samuel Helps HR Investors LinkedIn New CFO Personal Branding Recruiters Social Media Speaking and Training Successful CFO Succession Planning Talent Management Team Structuring The Strong CFO Training and Development Wiley
  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Contact Information

You can reach Samuel by:

Telephone
San Francisco: +1 (415) 738-2070
Montreal: +1 (514) 907-0925

Email: [email protected]

Copyright © 2011-2016 - Samuel Dergel (Dergel CFO Search & Consulting Inc.) Note: Opinions expressed on this website are the personal opinions of Samuel Dergel only, and not any other person or entity, unless attributed otherwise.